Private Chef vs Catering: What’s Best for Your Small Event?

‍

Feeling overwhelmed planning food for your next small event?

‍

Whether you're planning an intimate family gathering, a girls’ night in, or a garden BBQ on a sunny afternoon, food is often at the heart of the experience. But not everyone wants to spend hours prepping, cooking, and cleaning—especially if you’re hoping to actually enjoy your event. If you’re looking for help, you’re probably considering a few small event catering options, wondering whether to go with a private chef or a traditional caterer. The challenge? It’s not always clear which is the right fit. You might be asking: What’s the real difference between the two? Which one will feel more personal? Which is better value? At HOMETAINMENT, we work closely with both private chefs and clients to deliver unforgettable at-home dining experiences, so we’ve created this comparison to help you weigh up the pros and cons of private chefs vs catering—with real insight into what each option brings to the table.

‍

Traditional Catering: Familiar, Efficient, and Great for Groups

‍

Catering is typically the go-to for larger events or where you need to feed a crowd quickly and affordably. If you’ve ever attended a corporate event, a wedding reception, or even a big birthday celebration, chances are you’ve experienced the typical catering setup. Food is often pre-prepared off-site and brought in trays or boxes, ready to serve buffet-style or as a set menu. This can be ideal when your priority is volume over finesse. One of the biggest strengths of catering is efficiency. Caterers are often set up to handle large guest counts, with systems in place to ensure food arrives on time and ready to serve. If you're planning a casual event or just need to keep things moving smoothly, this can be a huge plus. Pricing is also often more cost-effective per head, particularly for fixed menus or when you opt for buffet service. Most caterers also provide full-service packages that include setup, basic staff, and post-event cleanup, which can relieve some of the logistical stress. That said, there are trade-offs. Traditional catering tends to be less personalised. Menus are often fixed or semi-custom, and it’s rare that you’ll have direct contact with the person who’s actually cooking the food. The food is also usually prepared in advance and reheated on-site, which can affect the overall freshness and flavour. Presentation is often simpler, and while efficient, the experience can feel a bit more transactional. You’re hiring a service, not a storyteller. And if you care about the journey of the ingredients or a creative flair in the plating, catering might not quite hit the mark.

‍

Private Chefs: Personalised, Elevated, and Ideal for Intimate Events

‍

Now let’s talk about private chefs. Hiring a private chef is an entirely different kind of experience—more immersive, more personal, and often more memorable. Rather than ordering food for delivery or setup, you're essentially inviting a skilled professional into your home to craft and serve a bespoke meal, created specifically for your event. One of the biggest benefits is the opportunity to customise every detail. Private chefs work directly with you to develop a menu tailored to your preferences, dietary needs, and even the theme or tone of your gathering. Whether you’re gluten-free, vegan, obsessed with Mediterranean flavours, or want a five-course French tasting menu, a private chef can bring that vision to life in a way that feels intimate and completely unique. The experience itself is also a key part of the appeal. Unlike caterers, private chefs typically cook and plate food live, right in your kitchen or event space. This not only guarantees freshness and flavour, but also adds a sense of theatre to the evening. It’s not just food—it’s entertainment. Guests can watch the chef at work, ask questions, or learn about the ingredients and inspiration behind the dishes. The storytelling aspect, the plating, the chef’s personality—it all adds up to something that feels elevated and special. However, private chefs aren't the right fit for every event. Because you're hiring someone to create and serve dishes from scratch, the cost per guest may be higher than a catering company, especially when using premium ingredients. You may also need to consider the limitations of your home kitchen. If your space is small or lacks certain equipment, the chef might need to adjust the menu or bring extra tools. Additionally, while some private chefs can provide waitstaff or hosts, this is often an additional cost—so it’s worth checking what's included in the service. And of course, private chefs are best suited to smaller groups. They usually specialise in intimate dinners or smaller parties where they can maintain quality and attention to detail. If you're planning a party for 50+ people, a single private chef likely won't be able to scale the experience in the same way a catering company can.

‍

The Personal Touch: Why Private Chefs Might Be a Better Fit for Small Events

‍

When it comes to small event catering options, the choice between a private chef and a caterer often comes down to the kind of experience you want to create. A private chef offers something more tailored, interactive, and emotionally engaging. It’s not just a meal—it’s a moment. At HOMETAINMENT, we’ve found that for smaller events—think dinner parties, garden soirees, or intimate celebrations—a private chef gives you far more flexibility and a better overall result. You have a direct line to the person preparing your meal, which means there’s no miscommunication or missing details. You can discuss allergens, make last-minute tweaks, or even request a signature dish that means something personal to your guests. There’s also a higher sense of accountability. When you book a caterer, you often don’t know exactly who’s in the kitchen or managing the process. But when you hire a private chef, that chef’s name and reputation are on the line. They’re more likely to go above and beyond to make your event memorable. That one-to-one connection brings a sense of trust and reliability that many of our clients truly value. And here’s something our clients absolutely love: when you book a private chef with HOMETAINMENT, the cleanup is handled, too. That means no post-party dishes, no scrubbing pans in your best outfit—just the chance to actually enjoy your own event, from start to finish.

‍

‍

Which Should You Choose?

‍

Both catering and private chefs have their place in the world of event planning. Catering can be a great solution when you need to serve lots of people efficiently, stick to a tight budget, or keep things casual. It’s practical, tested, and gets the job done. But if you want to elevate your evening, create a meaningful dining experience, or simply enjoy restaurant-quality food in the comfort of your home, then hiring a private chef is hard to beat. You get more control, more creativity, and ultimately, more joy from the experience. At HOMETAINMENT, we’d be lying if we said we didn’t favour private chefs—after all, we’ve seen firsthand just how powerful and memorable a chef-led experience can be. And when you book through our platform, it’s all designed to be seamless. Browse through our curated list of experienced chefs, chat directly with them about your event, and book with confidence. Whether you're looking for a themed tasting menu, a showstopping main, or a relaxed alfresco feast, we’ll help you find the perfect match. So if you’re planning a small event and want food that’s fresh, personalised, and beautifully presented, a private chef might just be your new best friend. Why not take a look at our private chef options here or click here to request a quote today and let us help you turn your next gathering into something unforgettable.

‍